The great diet hoax

The human animal has never been fatter, sicker, and weaker than it is today, and it only gets worse every year. The more “nutritionists” we get, the more vegetables we stuff into our bodies, the more bikes and treadmills we buy, the more powders and superfoods we waste money on, the worse it gets.

We actually eat less meat than ever before. We have never exercised more, counted more calories, or swallowed more pills, followed more “experts” on social media, or debated more in the daily press.

Yet life expectancy is declining, and disease statistics are skyrocketing, and it's almost as if we're just dying slowly, constantly deteriorating, instead of truly living all the strong, good years a human life should contain, until we're really old, and naturally "tired of days."

How could things go so wrong with this proud, beautiful human animal, with its broad shoulders and narrow waist, who could outrun a deer?

We have to go back to Ancel Keys' Minnesota Starvation Experiment from 1944-45, which is one of the most infamous nutrition studies in modern times.

The study revealed how the human animal can be kept in a state of constant hunger, weakness and mental distress by depriving us of nutritious food – something that the last century's Big Food and Big Pharma seem to have perfected, by finding lots of ways to make us afraid of meat and fat and everything that can make us full and nourished, and instead pouring over us lots of nutritionally empty taste bombs, which we stuff into us whether we want to or not.

Everyone wants to be slim and healthy, so why do we eat all the time? Why do we eat ourselves fat, while we dream of being slim?

This is NOT our fault. We are not lazy and useless with a lack of willpower – this is a cunning design, honed over many decades, and we are fooled.

The Minnesota Experiment – ​​A Design for Suffering

The experiment was conducted during World War II and aimed to study the effects of starvation and how to rehabilitate malnourished people. 36 healthy young men volunteered and were subjected to semi-starvation over a period of six months. They were given only about 1 calories per day, mainly from bread, potatoes, cabbage, root vegetables and lean soups – a diet almost identical to the modern recommended plant-based diet.

The results were disastrous:

• Severe weight loss and muscle loss – not just fat, but vital muscle mass disappeared.
• Extreme hunger – the participants became obsessed with food, dreamed about food, talked only about food.
• Mental disorders – they developed anxiety, depression, irritability and social withdrawal.
• Metabolic damage – their resting metabolism crashed, their body went into full survival mode.
• Decreased testosterone and libido - they became asexual and lost all vitality.

A study in how to keep people sick and addicted

So if anyone wonders why people today are walking around hungry, tired, and chronically ill, just look at the Minnesota experiment. The study proves that high carbohydrate intake and low fat intake lead to physical and mental collapse – and yet this is the recipe on which modern dietary recommendations are based.

But this is where it gets really interesting: Ancel Keys used this study to understand how to manipulate the physiology and psychology of the human animal.

He now knew that a lean, starch-based diet not only made people weak and passive, but also obsessed with food, making them perfect customers for the food industry and later the pharmaceutical industry.

The Big Lie – How Keys Created the Modern Diet

After the Minnesota study, everyone should have understood that fat and animal products are essential to life. Instead, Keys went right ahead with her massive bluff about saturated fat and cholesterol, selling the idea that natural animal products were dangerous.

Keys released a famous graph in 1953, which allegedly showed a strong correlation between fat intake and deaths from cardiovascular disease. The problem? He had data from 22 countries, but he only chose to talk about 6 – a minority of them, which fit his hypothesis. Had he included more, the connection between fat and heart disease would have disappeared.

In his later infamous Seven Countries Study He continued this trick. He selected specific countries where people ate less saturated fat and had lower rates of heart disease, while excluding countries that showed the opposite. For example:

• Finland and the United States, with high fat intake and a lot of heart problems, were given a place – because they supported his narrative.
• France and Germany, which ate a lot of saturated fat but had few heart problems, were ignored.
• The Netherlands and Sweden, with high fat intake and low heart disease rates, were also not included.

Greece during Lent – ​​another manipulation move

When Keys visited Greece to collect data, he arrived, surprisingly, during Orthodox Lent—a period when large parts of the population temporarily abstain from meat and dairy products. This made fat intake in Greece appear lower than it actually was, and he used these figures to bolster his hypothesis.

But after the fast, the Greeks ate large amounts of animal foods again—something that was never included in the analysis. This was either a gross methodological error or a deliberate manipulation to support the narrative that low fat intake led to less heart disease.

What do you think?

How Eisenhower's Heart Attack Helped the Diet Hoax

President Eisenhower's famous heart attack in 1955 was a gift package for Ancel Keys, and the diet hoax he ran and patched together. Before this, heart disease was relatively rarely discussed, but when the American president himself was stricken, it suddenly became a national crisis.

This gave Keys a perfect platform to sell his diet-heart hypothesis, and he knew how to take full advantage of the situation.

After his heart attack, Eisenhower was subjected to a dietary experiment in which he cut back on butter, eggs, and red meat, and instead ate lean meat, margarine, and vegetable oils—exactly what Keys recommended. Yet Eisenhower got six more heart attacks before he died in 1969.

But instead of acknowledging that the low-fat diet was a failure, it was used as evidence that people needed to cut back on saturated fat even more, and the population listened and nodded. Heart disease, previously virtually unknown, was affecting not only the president but an increasing number of adult men.

During this period, Keys also gained entry into the American Heart Association (AHA), which had previously been skeptical of his ideas. However, after the AHA began receiving large donations from the food industry (especially from companies that produced vegetable oils), they suddenly changed their stance and began promoting the low-fat diet as the solution to cardiovascular disease.

The perfect time for a dietary revolution

Eisenhower's heart attack triggered panic among the population, and the US government was desperate for a solution. Ancel Keys was ready with his simple explanation: saturated fatty acids clog the arteries, and people should replace butter and meat with grains, fruits and vegetable oils.

This was quickly embraced as official policy, paving the way for the great low-fat scam.

A defining moment in nutritional history

Had Eisenhower never had a heart attack—or had someone pointed out that his diet wasn’t working—the story might have been different. Instead, the heart attack and the widespread panic that spread through the population were used to cement a theory that was never proven, and which has undoubtedly led to faulty dietary advice and an epidemic of metabolic disease.

The consequence: The world's biggest nutrition hoax

By manipulating data and ignoring conflicting evidence, Keys thus created the foundation for the modern fat phobia.

This led to:

• Demonization of natural animal fats, and of meat.
• The rise of chemically extracted vegetable oils and margarines.
• Industrialization of "heart-friendly" factory foods with endless ingredient lists.
• A health disaster with increased obesity, perpetual hunger, diabetes, cancer and heart problems.

The Seven Countries Study is now widely seen as a nutritional fraud, but the damage was already done. Health authorities around the world bought the hoax and stubbornly stand by it to this day.

From experiment to modern slavery

The Minnesota Starvation Experiment showed that a person without enough fat and protein will mentally and physically disintegrate. However, this was not used to help people – it was used to create a society of hungry, sick, and addicted consumers. The modern world is simply a full-scale Minnesota experiment.

The treatment? Eat your fill of meat and fat.

Minnesota Starvation Experiment

The Starvation Experiment

Remembering Ancel Keys and the Minnesota Experiment

The Lipid–Heart Hypothesis and the Keys Equation Defined the …

Minnesota Starvation Experiment - Wikipedia

Ancel Keys' Cholesterol Con, Part 1 – CrossFit

The psychology of hunger – American Psychological Association

Legacy of Nutritionist Ancel Keys – Mayo Clinic Proceedings

THE MINNESOTA STARVATION STUDY - SAGE Publishing

Ancel Keys' Cholesterol Con, Part 2 – CrossFit

The Minnesota Semi-Starvation Experiment: What It Teaches Us...

The Effects of Starvation – InsideOut Institute

Keys, cholesterol and rabbits - Zoe Harcombe

Lipid hypothesis - Wikipedia

MORE SOURCES

Photo: Shutterstock license

Anyone can comment by logging in with their Facebook or Google accounts.. Norwegian Carnivory is not health care. You must seek medical attention for medical problems.

Written 2025 © Norwegian Carnivory